The short answer...
Discounts can help your business make more money, but only if they generate enough additional gross profit to justify the reduction in price. If customers would have bought from you anyway, you're simply giving profit away.
A 10% discount on a sale with a 40% gross profit margin reduces the gross profit on that sale by 25%. Before offering, continuing or removing a discount, understand its impact on profitability, customer behaviour and cash flow.
Customer discounts can increase business profitability if they generate enough additional sales, encourage repeat purchases or fill otherwise unused capacity. However, if customers would have purchased at full price anyway, discounts simply reduce your gross profit. Before offering a discount, you need to understand its financial impact and how much additional business it needs to generate.
I was recently asked by the owner of a beauty salon whether she should continue offering discounts to customers over 60.
However, I believe a better question to ask is: are your discounts helping your business make more money, or are they costing you money?
This is exactly the sort of question where understanding your business numbers can completely change the decision.
How do discounts affect gross profit?
Many businesses start offering discounts to certain types of customer because it feels like the right thing to do.
Perhaps you offer an over-60s discount because it helps fill quieter appointment slots, rewards loyal customers or simply feels like good customer service. Perhaps you copy what your competitors or other businesses do.
And none of those reasons are necessarily wrong.
The problem comes when the discount continues simply because nobody has stopped to work out whether it benefits the business or not.
Imagine you charge £50 for a treatment and give a 10% discount.
The customer pays £45.
At first glance, you might think, “It’s only £5.”
If your gross profit was £20 on the original £50 sale, your gross margin was 40%. After the 10% discount, you receive £45 but still have the same £30 of costs, leaving £15 gross profit. Your gross margin has therefore fallen to around 33%.
If you have 500 discounted transactions a year, that’s £2,500 of revenue you’re not receiving.
More importantly, the real question isn’t even whether you’ve lost £2,500 of revenue.
It’s what did you get in return for giving it away?
If those customers would have bought from you anyway, the discount may simply be reducing your profit.
If the discount encourages customers to visit when they otherwise wouldn’t, fills appointments that would have been empty or increases how much they spend with you, the answer could be very different.
This is why blanket rules about discounts rarely work.
What are the disadvantages of offering discounts?
Discounting can have a domino effect, affecting several areas of the business at the same time.
A lower gross profit is likely to reduce cashflow.
That could mean there’s less cash to invest in the business (such as a new hire, more marketing, new equipment, etc).
Discounts become expected.
That could mean your customers and your team get used to customers receiving cheaper prices, making it harder to increase prices later.
Discounts attract more price-sensitive customers.
That could mean an increasing proportion of your customers receive discounts and don’t pay full price – resulting in profits flatlining despite higher sales.
Discounts waste time
You and your team could spend hours managing complicated pricing arrangements, explaining exceptions or dealing with customers who expect discounts.
This is where a proper business financial strategy becomes valuable.
Instead of asking, “Can we afford to give this discount?”, ask:
“What does this discount achieve, and is there a better way of achieving the same result?”
How to use discounts without damaging profitability
Measure the real financial impact
Before changing anything, understand exactly what the discount is costing you and what you are getting back.
Look at the number of customers receiving the discount and ask yourself:
- How frequently do they purchase?
- What is their average spend?
- What is the gross margin on all their spend?
- Do they refer other customers who go on to pay full price?
- Would they realistically remain a customer without the discount?
You can do this by creating a simple customer analysis in your management accounts or spreadsheet, comparing discounted customers against full-price customers over the last 12 months.
Don’t just look at sales.
Look at gross profit, frequency of purchase, average transaction value and contribution to overheads.
You may discover that your discounted customers are actually some of your most valuable customers.
Or you may discover the opposite: they’re buying exactly the same services as everyone else, at a lower price, without providing any additional benefit to the business.
You won’t know until you look.
Replace blanket discounts with targeted offers
A blanket discount says, “You belong to this group, therefore you automatically get a cheaper price.”
A targeted offer says, “We want to encourage this particular behaviour.”
That’s a much more commercially useful approach.
For example, rather than giving every over-60s customer 10% off every appointment, you could offer a discount during traditionally quieter periods, create an off-peak package or provide an incentive for booking multiple appointments in advance.
The implementation is relatively simple: identify your quieter days, times or services, then use the discount specifically to generate additional demand where you have spare capacity.
That way, you’re not reducing the price of sales you were likely to make anyway.
You’re using pricing strategically to increase business cash flow and improve business profitability.
Test what happens if you reduce or remove it
You don’t necessarily need to make a dramatic decision overnight.
Instead, treat the discount like any other business assumption and test it.
You could reduce the discount from 10% to 5%, remove it for new customers, restrict it to certain days, or replace it with another benefit and then monitor customer behaviour.
Track customer numbers, sales, average spend, gross profit and repeat bookings before and after the change.
This is particularly useful because business owners often worry that customers will leave if a discount disappears.
Sometimes they will.
But often they won’t.
There will be some customers who will moan if they see the discount they’ve been receiving for years is removed or reduced.
This is to be expected because people tend to react more strongly when they feel they are losing a benefit they have become accustomed to.
To deal with any moans and customer concerns you need to prepare scripts that everyone in the business uses to explain to customers why the change has been made.
You may find that most customers will continue buying because the product or service is valuable enough to them.
Look at customer value rather than customer type
“Over 60” is a customer characteristic.
It isn’t necessarily a measure of customer value.
You could have two customers who are both over 60 but have completely different values to your business.
One might spend £40 once a year.
The other might spend £150 every month, purchase additional services and recommend several friends.
So rather than asking, “Should over-60s receive a discount?”, ask “Which customers are genuinely valuable to us, and what do we want to encourage them to do?”
You can then segment your customers according to factors such as frequency, spend, profitability, loyalty, referrals and the services they purchase.
This helps you understand your business numbers at a much deeper level.
And once you understand them, you can make pricing decisions that support the business you want to build.
The Key Takeaways
The answer to “Should I continue to give discounts to some of my customers?” isn’t automatically yes or no.
The important thing is to understand the commercial reason behind the discount.
Don’t confuse revenue with profit.
A discount reduces revenue, but the real question is what happens to gross profit and cash.
Don’t assume customers need the discount.
Test what actually happens when you change it.
Use discounts strategically.
If a discount fills otherwise empty capacity or encourages additional spending, it may have a valuable role.
Look at customer value rather than demographics.
The most valuable customers aren’t necessarily the ones who fit a particular age group or category.
Make decisions from your numbers – not your assumptions.
This is one of the simplest ways to improve business profitability and increase business profits.
Lastly, don’t look at a discount in isolation.
Look at your pricing, margins, customer behaviour, capacity, overheads, cash flow and overall business financial strategy together.
Got questions about your discounts or pricing?
If you’d like greater clarity on your numbers and how discounts impact your business then get in touch today.
To get in touch you can drop us an email to [email protected] or call one of the team on 0161 410 0020.
Disclaimer
You must take professional advice before making any decisions based on the information that you have learnt here. While every effort has been made, to make sure it is accurate it cannot be precisely tailored to your personal circumstances. This article is for general information only and no action should be taken, or refrained from, as a result of this information. Professional advice should be taken based on specific circumstances in each individual case. Whilst we endeavor to ensure that the information contained in the article is correct, no liability will be accepted by Krystal Clear Accounting which is a trading name of Kim Marlor Associates Ltd or damages of any kind arising from the contents of this communication, or for any action, inaction or decision taken as a result of using any such information.